Spotting fake cards

The key signs that expose fakes of Magic, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards, from the light test to the print pattern.

Where cards are worth money, there are fakes. The good news: the vast majority of them fail a few simple checks straight away, because genuine cards use materials and printing methods that are hard to imitate cheaply. You need no special lab for this, just light, your fingers and, if in doubt, a second card that is guaranteed genuine for comparison.

1. The light test

Genuine cards of the major games have a thin, opaque black core between two paper layers. Hold the card up to a bright lamp and hardly any light should shine through. Many fakes are made of solid paper or cardboard. They let light through clearly. (Exception: some very old prints; there it's worth comparing with a genuine card of the same age.)

2. Feel and flex

Genuine cards have a fine linen texture on the surface that shows as a matte pattern when tilted in the light. Fakes are often too smooth and too glossy, or the other way around, too rough. On a gentle (!) flex a real card springs back cleanly; cheap fakes crease or stay wavy.

3. The print under a loupe

With a simple loupe or your phone's zoom you can see the dot pattern of the print. Genuine cards show a clean, regular rosette dot grid; fakes often look washed out, have wrong colours or a coarse inkjet pattern. Pay special attention to small text like copyright lines, set symbols and the collector number. That's where fakes regularly fail on sharpness.

4. Colours, borders and corners

Compare the colour tone and border width with a genuine card from the same set. Fakes are frequently too dark, too pale, or have uneven borders and corners cut too sharp or too round. On Pokémon cards the yellow back detail and its alignment is a classic checkpoint.

5. Common sense

The strongest check is the price. A card that costs 80 euros on Cardmarket but is offered somewhere “sealed” for 8 euros is almost certainly a fake or a proxy. This is exactly why a known market price as a reference is so valuable. TCG-Completist shows it for every card and makes outliers obvious at once.

If you buy deliberately via the Cardmarket links from sellers with ratings, the fake risk is low anyway. Be especially careful with single offers from abroad, “collection clearances” at dream prices and unsealed “boosters”.

More from: Value & prices

Working out what your collection is worthHow to realistically find out what your cards are worth: market prices, condition, foils and the difference between catalogue value and actual sale.How we calculate pricesWhere the prices on TCG-Completist come from, what trend, “from” price and 30-day average mean, how the price to complete a set is calculated and why some prices are flagged as unreliable.
New
Setting Up a Price Alert: Get Cards Cheaper Without Constant SearchingHow to set a target price for wishlist cards or whole decks, when the email arrives and how to set alerts for a whole list at once.
New
Understanding the display ranking: how to read ×2.23, budget and variationHow the display ranking on TCG-Completist works: what the number ×2.23 means, how to find the right display or booster for your budget and what “Solid figures” and “Rough estimate” mean.